Iran

Viewing 8 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #11474
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      So it seems Trump is about to escalate significantly. I find this to be insanely dangerous and idiotic. The Iranians haven’t directly retaliated in the USA or attacked our assets around the globe, despite the fact that we killed their religious leader and about a third of their high level government officials. They have suggested the will go “apocalyptic” if Trump goes further and does the type of shit that is rumored.

      Play dangerous games; win stupid prizes… or whatever the saying is. And by that, I mean I am quite concerned about the USA and our assets around the globe.

      For decades the Pentagon and everyone with half a brain war-gamed wars with Iran. They all knew it was extremely dangerous. If we were going to go to war against a country like Iran, we would need a big coalition and a strategy. But Trump spent a couple years alienating our allies and partners and then half-assed his way into this war. And now, instead of dialing it back, he’s doubling down.

      I think this is moronic of epic proportions and I’m actually worried about our country. Call me paranoid. That’s fine. I hope I’m wrong. We may win some battles, but I don’t expect we’ll win the war in the long wrong (though I hope we do). And I think it will bite us and Israel in the ass, to say the least. I suspect we will feel it at home, unfortunately.

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

    • #11477
      MickMick
      Participant

      I don’t know enough of the backstory. I’m glad that someone is punishing a country that took our citizens hostage, calls us the Great Satan and threatens to destroy us regularly.

      At the same time, I hate war, it’s long-term bad for the economy, and I feel like our support for Israel has motivated this morass. I can’t believe we couldn’t get to a middle ground.

    • #11478
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      >I don’t know enough of the backstory.

      Trump doesn’t either. That’s the fucking problem.

      It also looks like Trump is doing a speed run to fuck over the Middle East. It’s insane. He’s destabilized the region and abandoning the Arabs at the same time.  Iran could well take over Kuwait and their oil and they’re fucking over Saudi Arabia while Trump tells the Saudis they’re on their own. I guess Witkoff and Kushner got a better deal with Putin, so who needs the Saudis anymore. I seriously hope I’m wrong. But if you listen to Trump “we have Venezuela and Greenland”, so it’s all cool. JFC.

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

    • #11479
      MickMick
      Participant

      “Iran could well take over Kuwait and their oil.”

      How are they going to do that? Iraq is between Iran and Kuwait, as is the Persian Gulf. American has eight military bases in Kuwaid, one in the UAE, two in Saudi Arabia with more than 25,000 personnel, to say nothing of the more than 20 U. S. Navy war ships in the middle east, including two carrier strike groups, multiple destroyers, a cruiser, a littoral combat ship and an expeditionary sea base.

    • #11481
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      Iraq doesn’t meaningfully sit between the two countries. Do you think in a real war Iran gives a shit about the ~70 mile sliver of land between them?

      How? Iranian-backed militant networks, sabotage, cyberattacks, or direct Iranian retaliation after Trump’s escalation. Kuwait has already experienced missile and drone attacks against American military installations on its territory. An October 14 Atlantic Council analysis actually suggested that Kuwait might be the Gulf country at greatest risk from the conflict, considering its geographic exposure and economic vulnerabilities.

      Iran doesn’t need to cross Iraqi territory to attack Kuwait. Iranian missiles and drones can easily cross that distance, and Iranian vessels can approach Kuwait directly through Gulf waters.

      Kuwait’s geographic proximity also explains why Iranian-backed militias in southern Iraq are such a concern. They’re practically next door.

      Whether it’s Iran or Iranian backed Shia militias, it’s a distinction without a difference. The American military presence hasn’t prevented Iran from repeatedly attacking U.S. installations in Kuwait. In fact, those bases make Kuwait a particularly attractive target.

      Just this week, Kuwait sentenced three men to death for an alleged Iranian-linked conspiracy to assassinate its interior minister, prompting a diplomatic confrontation with Tehran.

      Yes, a conventional Iranian takeover is highly unlikely. But I wouldn’t confuse the presence of American military forces with immunity from Iranian aggression and destabilization. Kuwait has very legitimate reasons to be nervous.

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

    • #11488
      AvatarHurlburt88
      Participant
    • #11491
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      Ok Hurlburt88. That’s an opinion piece. Summary: the military side of the Iran war is going well, so don’t elect a Congress that would defund it. It’s interesting to see the alternative reality some people live in. I assume you agree.

      I find the escalation a huge mistake. I hope to God I’m wrong.

      The Pentagon counted 18 dead and more than 830 wounded from the earlier strikes. A Pentagon inspector general report found that Iranian strikes damaged or destroyed hundreds of buildings and other structures at U.S. bases in Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar, the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Oman and elsewhere.

      The Gulf states have arguably been hit hardest. Around 80 energy facilities across the have been struck by Iranian missiles and drones, with repair costs estimated at ~$58 billion.

      The gulf countries were desperately trying to get us  not to escalate. But from the headlines just now, that is apparently too late.

      I worry this will escalate out of control. I believe Trump is going more by his gut than by any sober analysis of the consequences. I don’t think he gives a shit about the consequences and is surrounded by yes-men who are afraid to give him anything other than what he wants to hear.

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

    • #11492
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      By the way, unless there is regime change, Iran will emerge from this war much more powerful. This whole thing is epically shortsighted. But I realize MAGA, Trump, this community, conservatives, and the WSJ live in some alternate reality where this is somehow a good idea. Maybe I’m jumping to conclusions about all of you. But nobody here has said otherwise. Feel free to speak up. I remember every conservative back in the day was in favor of the Iraq war … until they weren’t.

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

    • #11494
      AvatarHurlburt88
      Participant

      I strongly agree that without regime change this is a huge setback for us and many countries.

      I also believe this regime has tested the limits of violence and intimidation, and will continue to do so.   Getting nuclear weapons will lock them in as ridiculously dangerous–look at how North KOrea is now essentially locked in.   The tactical appraoch without much of a coalition is incredibly short sighted, yet now may still be the best time to drive to a favorable end game.  Can still sign up partners.

Viewing 8 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.