The Midterm Elections

Homepage › Forums › Current Events Board › The Midterm Elections

Viewing 6 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #11464
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      Level setting:

      • House: Democrats ~91% on both prediction markets, Kalshi and Polymarket; traders project around 235–238 seats, 20 above the 218 majority.
      • Senate: Democrats ~65% on Kalshi and ~67% on Polymarket; projected 52 seats.
      • Full sweep: 63%. Democratic House with Republican Senate: 29%. Republican sweep: 9%.
      • Trend: the sweep probability has climbed from 39% in February to the mid-60s now. The Senate flipped from Republican-favored to a coin flip in the spring, during the Iran war, and has drifted toward Democrats since.

      Polls and Models:

      • Generic ballot: Democrats ahead by roughly 8–9.5 points depending on the average — Silver +9.1 (+9.6 among likely voters), Decision Desk +8.1, FiftyPlusOne +9. Silver’s model needs about a 4-point lead for the House given the new maps, and a 5–6 point lead for the Senate, so the current margin clears both.
      • Models: Silver gives Democrats 95% House / 75% Senate; Decision Desk 80% House / 57% Senate; Poliwave 87% / 57%. Models are a bit more cautious than markets on the House and roughly aligned on the Senate.
      • Trump’s net approval is around −23.

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

    • #11466
      MickMick
      Participant

      I think it will be a sweep. Part of the issue is Trump. Part of the issue is weaker R candidates. A huge part of the issue is the stealth inflation that is working its way through the economy and will for quite some time, led by fuel prices. I just filled my wife’s tank at the local “cheap” independent gas station… $6.15 per gallon. It’s created an environment where liars will thrive, and the Socialists will preach easier, cheaper everything if you just vote for them. And stupid people will likely vote for them.

      Since WWII, the incumbent’s party has lost 18 of 20 midterms in the House and 13 of 20 in the Senate. In 2018, Trump’s House lost 41 net seats, but gained two Senate seats. In 2022, the Dems lost nine seats, but that gave control to the Republicans.

      Those results, BTW, don’t generally influence the election two years later.

    • #11468
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      Democrats will win. That seems to be quite clear, whether you look at prediction markets, polls, leaked internal polls, or even focus groups of non-MAGA Republicans and conservatives. But Trump will pull some kind of bullshit. And by some, I mean a fuck ton.

      He’s already ramping up the “fraud” accusations to sew doubt about the election. Among other things, he’s already having “his” DOJ sue multiple states about not certifying elections or throwing out endless ballots. He’s announced arrests of “non-citizen voters”. He’s been threatening poll workers with imprisonment if they simply do their jobs and count all the votes. And much more.

      MAGA will eat all this shit up. The vast, vast majority of it (like 99.9% or 100%) will mostly likely end up being proven to be utter bullshit, like in 2020, but by then it won’t matter. He’ll have “discredited” the elections, sewn doubt, and most on the right will believe enough of it. And if all his BS fails, he’ll find some excuse(s) to void the results.

      Various things he may do or have his lackey do:

      • Mike Johnson will refuse to seat some Democrats.
      • Some states will refuse to certify their own ballots if Democrats win.
      • Same with some counties run by Republicans.
      • My long-shot, but not as long as it should be, is escalating the Iran war further, and then declaring some sort of state of emergency and, for all intents and purposes, arrogating more power to himself and effectively voiding the election results.

      It’s like one of those laws of thermodynamics. When you heat up a pot of water, you may not be able to predict where any specific atom or molecule is at any moment, but you know that everything is getting hotter. Likewise with this election. Trump has a fuck ton of shit planned and in progress. I don’t know all of it. I don’t know which of it will succeed. But I do know that in one form or another, his anti-democratic assault on our elections is a mortal lock.

      One thing I know for sure: Trump doesn’t know how to lose. He doesn’t know how to concede. He doesn’t believe in democracy unless he’s the winner. He’s shown a lifelong commitment to the idea that any loss by him or his side is illegitimate by definition. And he’s now built a political machine to enforce that concept.

      The next few months will be quite a shitstorm for our country due to Iran and for our democracy. That’s my prediction. I hope I’m wrong.

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

    • #11475
      MickMick
      Participant

      It’s interesting how the MAGA movement has continued to accelerate. I thought it was decelerating. By the polls, it looks like this:

      Year Estimated MAGA supporters Basis
      2015 15–30 million Movement emerges; year-end estimate
      2016 30–50 million Presidential campaign and election
      2017 45–70 million First year of Trump’s presidency
      2018 50–75 million Estimated support during first term
      2019 55–75 million Estimated support during first term
      2020 60–85 million Reelection campaign
      2021 50–80 million Post-election period
      2022 75–95 million National MAGA-support polling begins
      2023 60–95 million Different national surveys diverge
      2024 65–80 million Presidential election year
      2025 75–95 million Second Trump inauguration
      2026 75–90 million Latest national polling
      • This reply was modified 3 weeks, 2 days ago by MickMick.
    • #11486
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      Not sure where the data is from, but the table contradicts its own claim. From 2022 on, the ranges run 75–95, 60–95, 65–80, 75–95, 75–90 million. They overlap almost completely. That’s a plateau, not acceleration.

      Recent polling also suggests 2026 in the table is overstated:

      ABC/Washington Post/Ipsos, mid-October 2026: 22% of adults described themselves as supporters of the MAGA movement, and 75% said they were not. Applied to roughly 260 million US adults, that’s on the order of 55–60 million, well below 75–90.

      NBC News: 30 percent of registered voters identify as MAGA supporters, which works out to a similar ballpark.

      But I’ll grant that it remains one of the largest cults in American history.

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

    • #11487
      MickMick
      Participant

      How many Americans identify with the MAGA movement?

      Historical tracking | 2016–2026 | Updated November 1, 2026

      There is a measurable distinction between Americans who support Donald Trump electorally and Americans who identify with the MAGA movement itself.

      The most useful long-running measure comes from YouGov, which has tracked MAGA identification since September 2022.

      September 2022

      11%

      of U.S. adult citizens identified as MAGA Republicans

      May 2026

      19%

      of U.S. adult citizens identified as MAGA Republicans

      These figures indicate an eight-percentage-point increase in MAGA Republican identification between those two surveys. They do not mean that 19% represents everyone sympathetic to the broader movement.

      The key to an accurate annual history is to distinguish three measurements: self-identification with MAGA, favorable opinions of MAGA, and voting for Trump. Each captures a different degree or form of support.

      1. Annual trend: Americans identifying as MAGA Republicans

      2024 | Estimated Americans (millions)41.6M

      One selected poll per year, rather than annual averages. Estimates for 2023–2025 are modeled from Republican identification rates and approximate Republican population shares; the 2022 and 2026 percentages were reported directly for all adult citizens by YouGov.

      Year MAGA identification among Republicans Estimated U.S. adult citizens identifying as MAGA Republicans
      2022 (September) 38% 26.5 million
      2023 (January) 35% ~26 million
      2024 (December) 53% ~42 million
      2025 (December) 51% ~42 million
      2026 (May) 62% 47.5 million

      The Republican identification figures come from selected Economist/YouGov polls.

      The population estimates use U.S. adult-citizen counts and projections, including Pew Research Center’s estimates of 241.3 million in 2022 and 249.75 million in 2026.

      Pew Research Center

      Important limitation: The middle three population estimates use approximate Republican shares of adult citizens—31% in 2023, 32% in 2024, and 33% in 2025—to translate Republican-only polling percentages into national counts. Those population shares are modeling assumptions, not directly observed MAGA percentages in each poll. The 2023 survey was conducted in January, so the table should not be read as a year-end or annual-average series.

      There is also a survey-wording change beginning in late 2025: YouGov shifted from asking Republicans whether they were MAGA Republicans to asking Americans about being MAGA supporters, then identifying MAGA Republicans within that group. That adds a comparability caveat to the final observation.

      2. Broader MAGA movement support, including independents

      These surveys ask about identification or support across party lines, rather than only among Republicans.

      July 2025 — Wall Street Journal/NORC

      31%

      Considered themselves MAGA movement supporters

      ~84M

      U.S. adults

      August 2026 — UMass Amherst

      30%

      Identified with MAGA somewhat or very much

      ~81M

      U.S. adults

      The 2025 NORC survey found 31% support. The August 2026 UMass survey found 18% identified somewhat and 12% very much with MAGA.

      The population estimates above use the Census Bureau’s July 2025 estimate of approximately 269.8 million U.S. adult residents, also as a proxy for 2026.

      Because the pollsters used different questions and methods, the 31% and 30% figures should not be interpreted as evidence of a one-point decline.

      3. What the numbers tell us

      The evidence supports three observations:

      • The self-identified MAGA Republican population has expanded since 2022, based on YouGov’s continuing polling.

      • The broader MAGA movement includes people outside the Republican Party, so Republican-only counts understate its total reach.

      • Intensity matters. In August 2026, UMass estimated that approximately 12% of adults identified very much with MAGA, compared with 30% identifying at least somewhat.

        University of Massachusetts

      Reliable, comparable annual self-identification measurements are not available for every year from 2016 through 2021. I would leave those years unestimated rather than substitute presidential votes.

      For an ongoing annual tracker, I would maintain two distinct measures: a narrow measure of MAGA Republican self-identification, based on YouGov, and a broader measure of MAGA movement affiliation across all political parties, preferably using the same question and pollster each year.

      The most defensible current conclusion is that roughly 47 million U.S. adult citizens identified as MAGA Republicans in the May 2026 YouGov snapshot, while a broader definition of movement affiliation encompassed approximately 81 million U.S. adults in the August 2026 UMass survey. Those are different populations and definitions, not competing counts of exactly the same group.

    • #11493
      BeyondThunderdomeBeyondThunderdome
      Participant

      The narrow figures are based on adult citizens, while the broad figures are based on all adult residents. That makes the gap between the two look slightly bigger than a like-for-like comparison would.

      Anyway, I think MAGA has plateaued, as mentioned earlier. If you’re somehow trying to suggest otherwise, apparently, I guess we’ll see in a couple years. Trump as a proxy for MAGA has had ~30% support as a baseline for quite some time. He could kill someone on 5th avenue, “pal around” with Epstein for decades, get accused of rape by dozens of women, fuck our entire country up, destroy our alliances, align us with Russia, launch a nuclear weapon, tariff the world, engage in epic amounts of corruption, and many other things…  And that 30% would still support him. They are cult members.

       

      This guy gets it (only 24 second video):

      When you understand "the deep state" simply refers to the rule of law, it makes much more sense.

Viewing 6 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.