Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
MickParticipantWhy the assault on the Electoral College needs to fail:
November 17, 2026 at 7:42 pm in reply to: Greta Thunberg’s goal along along was to destroy capitalism… #11542
MickParticipantThe Swedes haven’t overthrown or destroyed anything since the Viking era…
They’re pacing themselves…
-
This reply was modified 4 days, 14 hours ago by
Mick.
MickParticipantI think that’s the opinion of a lot of people. I can’t remember the last time that I actually voted FOR a candidate, and the time I last remember doing so (Obama1), I felt sick about six months later.
MickParticipantThe more things change, the more they stay the same.
November 6, 2026 at 6:35 pm in reply to: Biggest stories of the midterm elections – #4 Rise of the Socialists #11523
MickParticipantNithya is just a treasure trove of wonderful, helium-filled, if-on-the-world-was-different policies, including:
1. Policing, crime and public safety
Raman’s record on law enforcement has been among the most controversial aspects of her political career.
– 1. Publicly supported “defund the police.” During her 2020 campaign, Raman embraced the movement to reduce police funding and shift resources toward other public services. She has subsequently moved away from that position.
– 2. Advocated a substantially smaller LAPD. Raman initially envisioned transforming the department into a much smaller armed force focused on circumstances requiring police intervention.
– 3. Supported reducing police hiring targets. In 2021, she joined an unsuccessful effort to lower then-Mayor Eric Garcetti’s police hiring goal by approximately 300 officers.
– 4. Opposed hiring 170 additional officers in 2026. She voted against Mayor Bass’s proposal to add 170 officers, citing the city’s financial difficulties, even though Bass argued the hires were needed to offset retirements.
– 5. Opposed a major LAPD compensation agreement. Raman voted against Bass’s 2023 police-union contract, which increased starting salaries and provided retention incentives. She argued that the agreement threatened the city’s financial stability.
– 6. Supported shifting some emergency response duties away from armed officers. Raman advocates using unarmed personnel for appropriate mental-health, behavioral-health, homelessness, and other nonviolent emergency calls.
– 7. Wants unarmed crisis responders integrated directly into 911 dispatch. Rather than making armed police officers the default response to every emergency, her proposal would assign different personnel based on the nature of the call.
– 8. Favors greater spending on violence prevention and social services. Her public safety approach includes funding community-based intervention, street medicine and other preventative programs as alternatives or complements to conventional policing.
– 9. Supports greater civilian oversight of the LAPD. Raman has called for stronger civilian accountability, performance standards, and increased scrutiny of police misconduct and liability costs.
– 10. Promised to replace LAPD Chief Jim McDonnell. During the mayoral campaign, Raman criticized McDonnell’s handling of federal immigration enforcement and protests. Her proposed timing shifted during the campaign before she pledged to begin replacing him on her first day.
– 11. Opposes LAPD cooperation with federal civil immigration enforcement. She argues that local police should not be perceived as assisting federal immigration agents, a stance that has generated disagreement over the proper role of municipal policing.
– 12. Supported restrictions on law-enforcement exchange programs with Israel. In her 2026 Democratic Socialists of America candidate questionnaire, she expressed support for halting those exchanges.
Important qualification: Raman has changed her position on police staffing. By February 2026, she said the LAPD should not shrink further from approximately 8,700 officers. She also voted for city budgets in 2021 and 2022 that increased police expenditures. It would therefore be inaccurate to portray her original 2020 position as her unchanged current policy.
2. Homeless encampments, street conditions and public spaces
This is arguably the area where Raman has faced her most persistent criticism from opponents who favor stronger enforcement of public-space restrictions.
– 13. Voted against prohibiting homeless encampments within 500 feet of schools and daycare centers. Raman opposed the city’s 2022 restrictions, arguing that they would displace homeless residents rather than solve homelessness.
– 14. Voted more than 60 times against expanding no-camping zones. Since 2021, she has repeatedly opposed measures sought by fellow council members to prohibit encampments at particular locations.
– 15. Opposed bans near parks and libraries. Raman resisted additional restrictions around public facilities used by families and children.
– 16. Opposed restrictions near freeway overpasses and other designated sensitive locations. She argued that moving encampments from one neighborhood to another does not constitute a sustainable solution.
– 17. Opposed relying on anti-camping enforcement as the primary way to clear sidewalks. Her longstanding position has been that actual shelter and housing placements should take precedence over enforcement-driven displacement.
– 18. Resisted criminalizing homelessness through camping violations. Raman has argued that creating criminal records for unhoused individuals can make securing future housing more difficult.
– 19. Subsequently softened her opposition to new no-camping zones. During the 2026 mayoral campaign, she said she would not obstruct council members seeking to establish such zones in their own districts. This was a significant departure from her earlier voting record.
– 20. Criticized Mayor Bass’s Inside Safe homelessness program. Raman has argued that extensive spending on temporary hotel and motel accommodations is inefficient and that too few participants transition into permanent housing.
– 21. Advocates shifting homelessness funding toward rental vouchers. She favors time-limited rental subsidies that allow eligible unhoused residents to move into apartments, with supportive services, rather than relying as heavily on hotel placements.
– 22. Supports expanding non-police street medicine and behavioral-health teams. She wants medical professionals and crisis responders deployed to encampments to provide treatment and assist residents in accessing housing.
– 23. Supports broad restructuring of homelessness spending and oversight. Raman wants performance-based funding, greater auditing of contractors and the city’s homelessness programs, and changes to programs that do not demonstrate sufficient results.
The most politically important distinction is between her earlier resistance to encampment restrictions and her current commitment to reduce the number of people living in tents and encampments by at least 50% before the 2028 Olympics. Her stated objective is now substantial reductions in street homelessness, primarily through housing and services rather than enforcement alone.
3. Rent control, landlord restrictions and private property
These positions have attracted opposition particularly from landlord organizations, property owners and some real estate interests, although many are popular with renters.
– 24. Supported lowering the maximum annual rent increase in rent-stabilized apartments to 4%. Raman helped advance the 2025 reform that set allowable annual increases generally within a 1%–4% range.
– 25. Pushed for an even stricter 3% rent-increase ceiling. Raman preferred a more restrictive maximum before the final 4% compromise was enacted.
– 26. Supported citywide just-cause eviction protections. These rules limit landlords’ ability to terminate tenancies without an accepted legal justification.
– 27. Supported restricting evictions for relatively small rent arrears. The city adopted protections against evictions for nonpayment when the outstanding amount is below one month’s fair-market rent.
– 28. Supported requiring landlords to report eviction notices to the city. These reporting rules increase oversight of eviction activity and create additional compliance requirements.
– 29. Supported publicly funded legal representation for qualifying tenants facing eviction. Raman helped advance a right-to-counsel policy, an approach opposed by some property-owner advocates concerned about costs and litigation.
– 30. Supports establishing an Office of Tenant Protections. The proposed office would more aggressively investigate landlord misconduct, enforce existing protections, and coordinate with attorneys providing tenant assistance.
– 31. Opposes loosening restrictions on Airbnb and other short-term rentals. She disagreed with Bass’s proposal to allow more second homes to be used as tourist accommodations, arguing that the city cannot afford to remove additional housing from the long-term rental market.
– 32. Supports tougher enforcement against illegal short-term rentals. Raman proposes a dedicated regulatory office, investigations, inspections and financial penalties for operators who violate the rules.
– 33. Supports restricting large-scale purchases of single-family homes by private equity firms. Her platform proposes prohibiting systematic acquisition of large numbers of houses by institutional investment firms.
– 34. Supports tightening California’s Ellis Act rules. Raman wants changes intended to reduce what she considers abusive evictions and the loss of affordable rental housing.
– 35. Supports greater public ownership of permanently affordable housing. Her housing platform includes city-owned or publicly controlled housing that remains affordable rather than eventually converting to market-rate prices.
These policies reflect a strong preference for tenant protections and government intervention in housing markets. The principal criticism from some property owners is that additional restrictions can discourage private investment or impose costs that are difficult to recover. Raman argues that tenant stability and housing affordability justify the interventions.
4. Housing density, zoning and development
Interestingly, Raman’s positions on new housing have also angered some traditional progressives and affordable-housing activists. She combines aggressive tenant protection with policies intended to make private development easier.
– 36. Supports adding duplexes, triplexes and fourplexes to some single-family neighborhoods. Her current platform calls for allowing these forms of additional housing near transit hubs.
– 37. Supports increasing residential density in neighborhoods historically reserved for single-family houses. She argues that restrictive zoning contributes to housing shortages and socioeconomic segregation.
– 38. Supports higher-density apartment development near major transit stations. Raman criticized Bass for opposing California Senate Bill 79, which allows taller buildings near qualifying transit stops, although Raman herself did not formally endorse the legislation.
– 39. Supports creating additional high-rise residential zones. Her housing platform calls for high-rise construction in selected areas to increase housing supply.
– 40. Wants to triple annual housing construction. Raman believes Los Angeles must substantially increase construction, including market-rate housing, subsidized affordable housing and publicly controlled housing.
– 41. Wants sharply accelerated housing approvals. Her proposal establishes a 60-day approval target for zoning-compliant developments and a 120-day target for projects requiring discretionary approval.
– 42. Supports limiting certain objections and appeals against housing developments. She proposes higher appeal fees for non-neighbors and fewer opportunities to appeal approved projects, reducing avenues for opponents to challenge construction.
– 43. Supports removing routine land-use decisions from elected officials. Raman proposes an independent professional board to handle land-use disputes, thereby reducing the City Council’s role in individual development decisions.
– 44. Supports reducing parking requirements in walkable and transit-rich neighborhoods. This could mean less required on-site parking for commercial uses and greater reliance on public transportation.
– 45. Originally supported Measure ULA, the real estate transfer tax commonly called the “mansion tax,” but later sought major exemptions. In January 2026, Raman proposed exempting certain multifamily properties, arguing that the tax discourages apartment construction. Affordable-housing activists criticized the proposal because the tax finances housing and homelessness programs.
– 46. Supports converting more offices into residential properties by easing regulatory obstacles. Her approach emphasizes removing development barriers and fees to make office-to-housing conversions more economical.
– 47. Supports broadening permitted construction methods and building types. Raman favors making it easier to use factory-built housing, mass timber and single-stairwell building designs where permitted under appropriate safety rules.
Political significance: These policies put Raman at odds with different constituencies for different reasons. Some homeowners resist neighborhood densification, while some tenant and housing activists object to measures such as reducing the scope of Measure ULA. Conversely, housing-supply advocates strongly support many of her zoning proposals.
5. Immigration, federal enforcement and sanctuary-city policies
Raman has taken strong positions limiting local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement.
– 48. Helped write Los Angeles’s sanctuary-city ordinance. The law restricts the use of city resources and personnel for federal civil immigration enforcement.
– 49. Supports prohibiting ICE operations on city-owned property. Raman wants to codify and expand restrictions preventing federal immigration authorities from using city facilities for immigration operations.
– 50. Wants city contractors to certify that they have no agreements with federal immigration-enforcement agencies. Her platform would impose new conditions on companies and organizations doing business with Los Angeles.
– 51. Supports preventing federal immigration authorities from accessing city surveillance information. Raman wants to ensure that license-plate reader data, third-party surveillance systems and other city-held information are not used for civil immigration enforcement.
– 52. Advocates increased taxpayer funding for immigration legal defense. She proposes expanding the RepresentLA program to provide greater legal assistance to residents facing deportation.
– 53. Supports accepting foreign identification documents for city programs. Her platform calls for broader use of consular IDs, foreign passports and Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers in determining eligibility for city services.
– 54. Supports emergency utility-bill relief for families affected by immigration raids. Raman proposes fee waivers for qualifying families experiencing the detention of a household member.
– 55. Supports city legal challenges against federal immigration authorities. She wants the City Attorney to challenge unlawful federal enforcement actions and pursue accountability when federal agents violate the law.
These positions may attract opposition from immigration-enforcement advocates, those concerned about city expenditures, and contractors facing additional requirements. Raman frames them as protecting residents’ rights and maintaining public trust in local government.
6. Transportation, automobiles, bike lanes and traffic enforcement
Raman is a strong proponent of reducing automobile dependence in Los Angeles, an approach that has provoked substantial controversy in a city where driving remains central to daily life.
– 56. Supports converting some vehicle travel lanes into protected bicycle lanes. She has criticized the cancellation of bicycle infrastructure projects because of concerns about congestion.
– 57. Supported the controversial Forest Lawn Drive bicycle-lane project. Raman criticized Bass’s decision to halt a plan that would have removed a vehicle lane to accommodate protected bicycle infrastructure. Opponents, including nearby cemeteries and neighborhood representatives, raised concerns about traffic and access.
– 58. Supports expanding permanent dedicated bus lanes. Her platform proposes giving buses exclusive or priority roadway space, including retaining as much of the Olympic bus-lane network as possible after 2028.
– 59. Supports expanded automated traffic enforcement. Raman proposes speed cameras and the return of red-light cameras, potentially replacing some officer-issued citations with automated enforcement.
– 60. Wants the LAPD to spend less time on equipment violations and pretextual traffic stops. She argues that police should prioritize speeding, impaired driving and dangerous driving behavior.
– 61. Supports changing traffic-signal priorities to favor pedestrians and public transportation. Her plans include prioritizing buses and trains at intersections and making pedestrian safety a central consideration.
– 62. Supports traffic-calming measures and street redesigns. These include speed humps, protected crosswalks, curb extensions and other physical changes that can reduce vehicle speeds or alter traffic flow.
Although critics worry about congestion, reduced road capacity and accessibility, supporters contend that these projects improve safety and offer transportation alternatives.
7. Climate, energy and environmental regulation
Raman supports substantial environmental intervention affecting utilities, construction, transportation and industry.
– 63. Supports ending neighborhood oil drilling in Los Angeles. She wants the city to prohibit new drilling and establish enforceable timelines for closing existing wells.
– 64. Supported requiring new buildings to be all-electric. Raman led the City Council’s 2022 effort to require all-electric construction. That ordinance was subsequently struck down by federal courts; she supports pursuing legally sustainable replacement regulations.
– 65. Supports a transition to 100% clean electricity by 2035. Raman wants LADWP and other city-controlled departments held accountable for emissions-reduction targets.
– 66. Supports a moratorium on new large-scale data centers unless specified environmental conditions are satisfied. She wants developers to secure clean power, limit water-system burdens and pay for the infrastructure their facilities require.
– 67. Supports greater public spending and incentives for electric vehicles and alternatives to driving. Her proposals include e-bike rebates, additional charging infrastructure and expanded electric vehicle-sharing programs.
These positions could encounter resistance from oil and gas interests, builders, utility customers concerned about costs, and data-center developers. The underlying environmental objectives, however, have substantial support among environmental organizations.
8. The 2028 Olympics and major municipal investments
Raman’s opposition to several major Olympic-related agreements distinguishes her from many established Los Angeles political and business leaders.
– 68. Originally opposed Los Angeles hosting the 2028 Olympics. In a 2020 candidate questionnaire, Raman opposed bringing the Games to the city, criticizing the approval process, financial planning and lack of public input.
– 69. Voted against the principal agreement with the LA28 Olympic organizing committee. She was one of only two council members to oppose the contract establishing the primary partnership between the city and organizers.
– 70. Voted against the 2026 Olympic services reimbursement agreement. Raman joined three other council members in opposing the arrangement governing repayment for services such as policing and sanitation. She argued that the city needed stronger financial protections and auditing rights.
– 71. Opposed the approximately $2.6 billion Los Angeles Convention Center expansion. Raman voted against the project despite support from labor and business groups that argued it would generate jobs and improve downtown’s competitiveness. She cited its potential long-term financial burden on the city.
Her current position is not that Los Angeles should cancel the Olympics. She says she wants the Games to succeed while minimizing financial risks to city taxpayers.
9. Labor policy and business regulation
– 72. Supported increasing the minimum wage for hotel and airport workers to $30 per hour by 2028. She supported the original wage-increase schedule, which encountered strong resistance from affected business interests.
– 73. Opposed an 18-month postponement of the $30 wage target. In May 2026, Raman joined three fellow DSA-aligned council members in opposing a compromise that postponed the wage schedule. Business groups had threatened a ballot initiative targeting the city’s business tax.
– 74. Advocates substantially reducing municipal cannabis business taxes. Her 2026 platform proposes replacing a flat 10% gross-receipts tax with temporary graduated rates between 0.25% and 6%, potentially reducing revenue from that tax in the short term.
– 75. Supports expanding opportunities for licensed cannabis consumption establishments and events. Raman wants the city to take advantage of California laws permitting cannabis cafés and consumption events under local authorization.
– 76. Supported dramatically reducing street-vending permit fees. She championed a reduction from approximately $541 to $27.51 and advocates further measures to make street vending easier to operate legally. Such efforts may concern some established businesses facing different regulatory expenses.
Notably, Raman is not uniformly opposed to business interests. Her opposition to some projects reflects fiscal concerns, while other parts of her platform seek to reduce permitting delays and regulatory costs.
10. Israel, Palestine and disagreements within the Democratic Socialists of America
Raman’s positions on Israel and Palestine are unusually contentious because they have sometimes angered both pro-Israel organizations and the more hard-line anti-Israel wing of her own political movement.
– 77. Accepted the endorsement of Democrats for Israel–Los Angeles in 2024. Her decision led the Los Angeles chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America to formally censure her, although it maintained its electoral endorsement.
– 78. Affirmed Israel’s right to exist. Raman has expressed this view while also criticizing Israeli military conduct, a combination that has led some DSA activists to challenge her commitment to their organization’s policies.
– 79. Described Israel’s military campaign in Gaza as genocide. She defended that characterization during the 2026 mayoral campaign, a position disputed by Bass and many pro-Israel advocates.
– 80. Declined to include the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement against Israel in her municipal campaign platform. Her position became the subject of intense disagreement within DSA. On November 2, 2026, its national political committee narrowly voted, 14–13, against rescinding her endorsement.
These are distinct political controversies: Raman has been criticized by different groups for taking positions they see as either too sympathetic to Israel or insufficiently sympathetic to it.
11. Other significant controversies involving her record
These are not additional policy positions, but they are important in assessing why Raman has faced criticism.
– Voting to confirm the police chief she now wants to replace. In 2024, Raman voted to confirm Jim McDonnell despite opposition from DSA colleagues. The organization issued a statement of disapproval. She subsequently campaigned on replacing him.
– Changing positions on police funding and the mansion tax. Her reversals became a significant issue in the mayoral campaign. Raman said changes reflected new information and changing circumstances; opponents characterized them as political inconsistency.
– Missing nearly 3,000 City Council votes since 2020. A September 2026 LAist analysis documented that number, although it also found that her attendance was roughly in line with many colleagues and that most missed votes would not have changed outcomes. Raman’s campaign cited scheduling conflicts involving her air-quality board responsibilities.
– Removal as chair of the City Council’s Housing and Homelessness Committee. In August 2026, council leadership removed Raman from the post, citing delayed committee business and difficulties advancing legislation. Raman alleged retaliation for challenging Bass.
– Comments about former LAPD Chief Daryl Gates. During an October debate, Raman referred to the LAPD’s earlier approach to immigration enforcement under Gates as a gold standard. Critics objected because of Gates’s broader policing record. Raman subsequently apologized, saying her remarks had been a mistake.
November 5, 2026 at 4:05 pm in reply to: Biggest stories of the midterm elections – #4 Rise of the Socialists #11521
MickParticipantNovember 5, 2026 at 10:36 am in reply to: Biggest stories of the midterm elections – #1 Blue Wave #11518
MickParticipantRight now, I’m pretty comfortable saying the Democrats have picked up 39 seats in the House. NBC News is projecting a 43 seat Republican loss. This combined loss of 50 House and Senate seats would rank Trump as having the 10th greatest loss in 25 mid-term elections over the last 100 years. Largest are as follows:
Ten largest midterm losses, 1926–2026
Negative numbers represent seats lost by the president’s party.
Rank Year President Party House Senate Combined loss 1 1938 Franklin D. Roosevelt D −72 −7 79 2 2010 Barack Obama D −64 −6 70 3 1946 Harry S. Truman D −55 −12 67 4 1994 Bill Clinton D −54 −8 62 5= 1930 Herbert Hoover R −52 −8 60 5= 1958 Dwight Eisenhower R −48 −12 60 7 1942 Franklin D. Roosevelt D −44 −9 53 8= 1966 Lyndon B. Johnson D −48 −4 52 8= 1974 Gerald Ford R −48 −4 52 10* 2026 Donald Trump R −43* −7* 50* November 5, 2026 at 10:26 am in reply to: Biggest stories of the midterm elections – #2 Impeachments to come #11516
MickParticipantExactly what the Democrats shouldn’t do.
Some Democrats have come out publicly to state that they need to concentrate on policy in favor of revenge. They have a big legislative agenda for the next 100 days, they need to get that done rather than get bogged down in lawfare. That includes Kamala Harris, Sherrod Brown, Rahm Emanuel, Sen. Tammy Duckworth, Rep. Pat Ryan of NY.
Other Democrats who have supported investigations but urge caution on impeachment include House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries, Sen. Tim Kaine, Rep. Jamie Raskin (senior House Democrat on Judiciary), Rep. Robert Garcia (Senior Democrat on Oversight), Sen. Jon Ossoff of Georgia, previously supported impeachment but became less committed to it during the past year.
MickParticipantDon’t forget Proposition 36 which reclassified misdemeanors that had originally been felonies as felonies once again. It increased penalties for drug and theft crimes.
Newsom was vehemently against Proposition 36, which passed in a landslide. Republicans said that $400 million was necessary to enforce it, Newsom said he would make $100 million available. Legislative leaders claimed that $375 million was voted, but only $50 million was used. And much of the $375 million was money “pulled” from other ballot initiatives for other purposes.
Gavin Newsom under fire for California’s Prop. 36 funding
Newsom realized that greater enforcement of laws would result in more incarceration, which he didn’t want, he wanted to point to lesser crime results.
MickParticipantI think Trump will accept the results of these midterms as he did the 2018 midterms, which also did not go well for him. My big hope is that he can continue to conduct the Iranian war to some sort of success. Iran is the most dangerous country in the world, with its unrepentant religious fundamentalist leaders, at odds with everyone, including their own public.
Totally agree. Incidentally, I’m convinced America will be a Muslim country inside of three generations.
MickParticipantHow many Americans identify with the MAGA movement?
Historical tracking | 2016–2026 | Updated November 1, 2026
There is a measurable distinction between Americans who support Donald Trump electorally and Americans who identify with the MAGA movement itself.
The most useful long-running measure comes from YouGov, which has tracked MAGA identification since September 2022.
September 2022
11%
of U.S. adult citizens identified as MAGA Republicans
May 2026
19%
of U.S. adult citizens identified as MAGA Republicans
These figures indicate an eight-percentage-point increase in MAGA Republican identification between those two surveys. They do not mean that 19% represents everyone sympathetic to the broader movement.
The key to an accurate annual history is to distinguish three measurements: self-identification with MAGA, favorable opinions of MAGA, and voting for Trump. Each captures a different degree or form of support.
1. Annual trend: Americans identifying as MAGA Republicans
2024 | Estimated Americans (millions)41.6MOne selected poll per year, rather than annual averages. Estimates for 2023–2025 are modeled from Republican identification rates and approximate Republican population shares; the 2022 and 2026 percentages were reported directly for all adult citizens by YouGov.
Year MAGA identification among Republicans Estimated U.S. adult citizens identifying as MAGA Republicans 2022 (September) 38% 26.5 million 2023 (January) 35% ~26 million 2024 (December) 53% ~42 million 2025 (December) 51% ~42 million 2026 (May) 62% 47.5 million The Republican identification figures come from selected Economist/YouGov polls.
The population estimates use U.S. adult-citizen counts and projections, including Pew Research Center’s estimates of 241.3 million in 2022 and 249.75 million in 2026.
Pew Research CenterImportant limitation: The middle three population estimates use approximate Republican shares of adult citizens—31% in 2023, 32% in 2024, and 33% in 2025—to translate Republican-only polling percentages into national counts. Those population shares are modeling assumptions, not directly observed MAGA percentages in each poll. The 2023 survey was conducted in January, so the table should not be read as a year-end or annual-average series.
There is also a survey-wording change beginning in late 2025: YouGov shifted from asking Republicans whether they were MAGA Republicans to asking Americans about being MAGA supporters, then identifying MAGA Republicans within that group. That adds a comparability caveat to the final observation.
2. Broader MAGA movement support, including independents
These surveys ask about identification or support across party lines, rather than only among Republicans.
July 2025 — Wall Street Journal/NORC
31%
Considered themselves MAGA movement supporters
~84M
U.S. adults
August 2026 — UMass Amherst30%
Identified with MAGA somewhat or very much
~81M
U.S. adults
The 2025 NORC survey found 31% support. The August 2026 UMass survey found 18% identified somewhat and 12% very much with MAGA.
The population estimates above use the Census Bureau’s July 2025 estimate of approximately 269.8 million U.S. adult residents, also as a proxy for 2026.
Because the pollsters used different questions and methods, the 31% and 30% figures should not be interpreted as evidence of a one-point decline.
3. What the numbers tell us
The evidence supports three observations:
-
The self-identified MAGA Republican population has expanded since 2022, based on YouGov’s continuing polling.
-
The broader MAGA movement includes people outside the Republican Party, so Republican-only counts understate its total reach.
-
Intensity matters. In August 2026, UMass estimated that approximately 12% of adults identified very much with MAGA, compared with 30% identifying at least somewhat.
University of Massachusetts
Reliable, comparable annual self-identification measurements are not available for every year from 2016 through 2021. I would leave those years unestimated rather than substitute presidential votes.
For an ongoing annual tracker, I would maintain two distinct measures: a narrow measure of MAGA Republican self-identification, based on YouGov, and a broader measure of MAGA movement affiliation across all political parties, preferably using the same question and pollster each year.
The most defensible current conclusion is that roughly 47 million U.S. adult citizens identified as MAGA Republicans in the May 2026 YouGov snapshot, while a broader definition of movement affiliation encompassed approximately 81 million U.S. adults in the August 2026 UMass survey. Those are different populations and definitions, not competing counts of exactly the same group.
MickParticipant“Iran could well take over Kuwait and their oil.”
How are they going to do that? Iraq is between Iran and Kuwait, as is the Persian Gulf. American has eight military bases in Kuwaid, one in the UAE, two in Saudi Arabia with more than 25,000 personnel, to say nothing of the more than 20 U. S. Navy war ships in the middle east, including two carrier strike groups, multiple destroyers, a cruiser, a littoral combat ship and an expeditionary sea base.
MickParticipantI don’t know enough of the backstory. I’m glad that someone is punishing a country that took our citizens hostage, calls us the Great Satan and threatens to destroy us regularly.
At the same time, I hate war, it’s long-term bad for the economy, and I feel like our support for Israel has motivated this morass. I can’t believe we couldn’t get to a middle ground.
MickParticipantIt’s interesting how the MAGA movement has continued to accelerate. I thought it was decelerating. By the polls, it looks like this:
Year Estimated MAGA supporters Basis 2015 15–30 million Movement emerges; year-end estimate 2016 30–50 million Presidential campaign and election 2017 45–70 million First year of Trump’s presidency 2018 50–75 million Estimated support during first term 2019 55–75 million Estimated support during first term 2020 60–85 million Reelection campaign 2021 50–80 million Post-election period 2022 75–95 million National MAGA-support polling begins 2023 60–95 million Different national surveys diverge 2024 65–80 million Presidential election year 2025 75–95 million Second Trump inauguration 2026 75–90 million Latest national polling -
This reply was modified 3 weeks, 2 days ago by
Mick.
MickParticipantI dunno, man. I’m not sitting through a two-hour video with ads. How about if you sum it up?
Incidentally, “the Deep State” doesn’t refer to the rule of law. That’s one of the spinniest spins that’s ever been spun. It refers to discretionary power held by unelected employees who ignore the will of the elected politicians and indirectly the will of the people. They do whatever they want because they’ll be there long after the elected politicians are gone.
The term originated in Turkey, and was applied in the USA when covert operations were deemed necessary during The Cold War, irrespective of who was President. Many of the excesses of the CIA (almost the definition of the Deep State) occurred during this period and haunt us today.
The Deep State references cabals of power. Republican President Eisenhower railed against the military-industrial complex in his farewell speech. In Eisenhower’s last full year, military expenditures were $48.13 billion. Last year, military expenditures were $916.65 billion, this fiscal year (which just closed) it will be $965 billion. There’s been 10x inflation since 1960, while military expenditures have gone up at twice that amount.
That is the deep state. An unelected group of individuals who built a government expenditure that is 20x what it was three generations ago.
-
This reply was modified 3 weeks, 2 days ago by
Mick.
-
This reply was modified 4 days, 14 hours ago by
-
AuthorPosts